This memo raises crucial questions about the former administration of former president Jovenel Moise in Haiti and their approach to the prison system. During their tenure, the administration appears to have overlooked the need to improve the living conditions of incarcerated individuals – a pressing human rights issue.
The administration has not adhered to the law stipulating a pre-trial before judgment and sentence, which is a fundamental part of a fair legal process. This apparent neglect raises serious questions about the administration’s commitment to justice and the rule of law.
At a town-hall meeting in Brooklyn, New York, in September 2017, these concerns were brought to the attention of the president. What was part of a tour to discuss a new proposed tax bill and review the proposed fiscal budget of that year with the Haitian diaspora.
The addressed concern was: “what steps does the administration plan to take to address these glaring issues in the penitentiary system?” This question remains unanswered, underlining the need to have a thorough investigation and public discourse on the matter.
In light of the most recent break at the penitentiaries in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, it becomes imperative to revisit that event, examining in detail what exactly transpired and what did not. An evaluation of the current state of law and order in Haiti is also urgently needed. On what did not occur overnight, but is the result of a long-standing often neglect and disregard of the rule of law, from the prison system to the judicial process.
Listing the reasons that were visited leading to the questions posed to the former president: The living conditions of prisoners have been a matter of grave concern, requiring urgent attention. Some individuals, who wished to remain anonymous due to their safety, have reported to us about a multitude of mistreatments of individuals at the two main penitentiaries in Haiti. This includes a lack of food, absence of educational resources, and inadequate sleeping areas. Those aside instances, it was reported that an estimated 100 prisoners were crammed into one small room. These inhumane conditions underline the severity of the situation and the dire need to have immediate intervention and improvement.
The recent break at the penitentiary in Haiti highlights that its urgent to pursue efficient reform and investment in the prison system. As well as the state of the country which needs a rebuild as a whole.
In terms of improvements, it’s difficult to point out any significant reforms, but the need remains there. This call leave the public wanting a complete overhaul of Haiti’s basic public sectors, including its practices and policies, that would be necessary.
The question of what the authorities have done to address these issues is pressing and demands transparency. The public, particularly the Haitian diaspora, has a right to know what steps are being taken to rectify this insecurity crisis. Accountability and justice to those wrongly detained, and justice to those victims of illegal individuals that have led to the escape from the prison of those criminals. These hopes here, cannot be achieved without a thorough examination of the penitentiary system and the implementation of comprehensive reforms.
Other significant arguments that have been pointed out to address this issue: The prison break in Haiti has evoked mixed feelings among the Haitian population. On one hand, there is a sense of relief to those who were illegally detained or wrongfully accused. The Haitian prison system, known to have its gross human rights violations, often failed to observe due process of law. Consequently, many individuals found themselves behind bars without a fair trial or concrete evidence supporting their accusations, leading to a pervasive sense of injustice among the populace.
On the other hand, there is also a sense of apprehension and concern. The prison break not simply unveils and exposes the inadequacy that permits the unlawful activities. A word to the Haitian government ‘brings into sharp focus the urgent need to have legal reforms to ensure due process of law before sentencing. This includes implementing legal safeguards to prevent unlawful detentions, ensuring fair trials, and holding accountable those responsible of miscarriages of justice.’ The fear is that without such reforms, the cycle of illegal detentions and wrongful convictions will continue unabated, undermining the rule of law and eroding public trust in the justice system.
To have a serious consideration to improve the living conditions of the inmates. This includes providing adequate food, educational resources, and suitable living areas.
The state of a country’s penitentiary system is a key indicator of its commitment to upholding justice, human rights, and the rule of law. A well-functioning justice sector that operates within the confines of the law is crucial for a country’s development. It ensures that everyone is held accountable for their actions, provides a deterrent against crime, and offers a means for peaceful resolution of disputes.
In Haiti’s case, the rebuilding of the penitentiary should be seen as an opportunity to overhaul the system and address long-standing issues. This includes ensuring that pretrial hearings are held, as stipulated by law, and improving the treatment of incarcerated individuals. Such reforms will not simply demonstrate Haiti’s commitment to justice and human rights but also promote societal stability and development.
Discussion about this post